LaborFest
LaborFest was established in 1994 to institutionalize the history and culture of working people in an annual labor cultural, film and arts festival.
How a San Francisco disability rights protest inspired the film ‘Being Heumann’
www.sfchronicle.com/entertainment/movies-tv/article/being-heumann-sf-disability-rights-22503279.php
By Pam Grady,
Contributor
Nov 3, 2026
Disability rights activist Judith Heumann, center, is joined by a delegation of handicapped protesters on their way to Washington at the San Francisco International Airport in 1977. Heumann, along with 100 other protesters, had just participated in the Section 504 sit-in at the Department of Health, Education and Welfare at the Federal Building in San Francisco.
Disability rights activist Judith Heumann, center, is joined by a delegation of handicapped protesters on their way to Washington at the San Francisco International Airport in 1977. Heumann, along with 100 other protesters, had just participated in the Section 504 sit-in at the Department of Health, Education and Welfare at the Federal Building in San Francisco.
Clem Albers/S.F. Chronicle
In 1977, a group of disabled activists took over a federal building in San Francisco. They stayed for 26 Days — a record that still stands as the longest occupation of a federal building by protesters.
Mounted by disabled activists led by Judy Heumann, the action aimed to convince Joseph Califano, the Carter administration’s secretary of health, education and welfare to enforce Section 504, a key component of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 that granted civil rights protections to people with disabilities.
Califano continued the delay in enforcing Section 504 that began during the Nixon administration, citing the expense of the accommodations that equality would require. He formed a committee with no disabled people on it to study the issue. But disabled people who spent their lives fighting for equal opportunity were done with being second-class citizens.
The drama of that standoff is at the heart of Siân Heder’s latest film, “Being Heumann.” Ruth Madeley (“Doctor Who”) plays the native New Yorker Heumann, with Mark Ruffalo cast as Califano.
More Information
“Being Heumann” (R) opens Friday, Nov. 6, in select Bay Area theaters before streaming on Apple TV on Friday, Nov. 13.
It was “Crip Camp,” Bay Area filmmakers Jim LeBrecht (an executive producer on “Being Heumann”) and Nicole Newnham’s Oscar-nominated documentary about a summer camp for disabled children, that introduced the “CODA” writer-director to Heumann. After reading the activist’s memoir, “Being Heumann,” Heder became excited at the prospect of making a film about her. In a triumph of timing, Heumann was on the verge of hiring a director for a proposed film when Heder reached out with her pitch.
“You could make a biopic of Judy, which would be incredibly interesting. There were all these chapters of her life that would have made a great movie,” Heder told the Chronicle. “But when I got to the section (about the protest), I was like, ‘Oh, this is a contained heist story.’“
Heder saw a model for that kind of contained, character-driven story in Sidney Lumet’s 1975 film about a bank robbery that becomes a media spectacle.
“There was something exciting for me in the way that ‘Dog Day Afternoon’ just drops you right into that story, and then you learn about the characters as you go,” she said.
Disability rights activist and Center for Independent Living founder Judith Heumann is photographed in an interview with the San Francisco Chronicle in 1980.
Disability rights activist and Center for Independent Living founder Judith Heumann is photographed in an interview with the San Francisco Chronicle in 1980.
Vince Maggiora/S.F. Chronicle
Heumann embraced the idea, choosing Heder to tell her story. When Heumann died in 2023, the director, who was in the midst of developing several projects, decided "Being Heumann” would be her next film.
Coming off the best picture Academy Award for “CODA” and the adapted screenplay she won for the film, Heder had the clout needed to get backing for a large-scale period drama she might never again have the opportunity to make.
The film required the San Francisco federal buildings and its surroundings to be meticulously recreated in Toronto, filled with a large ensemble of mostly disabled actors. The production also called for a large accessibility team.
Casting disabled actors, many unknown, to play people with disabilities was crucial. Beyond the irony implicit in casting able-bodied actors in a film about disabled people fighting for their rights, Heder believes only actors from the disabled community could fully inhabit those characters.
“For instance, thinking about ‘CODA,’ if you have an actor playing deaf, part of their work is always going to be, ‘OK, I need to be deaf and I need to be these other things.’ You put (deaf actor) Troy Krotsur in that role, and he's playing the moment,” Heder explained.
Ruth Madeley, left, with director Siân Heder on set of “Being Heumann.”
Ruth Madeley, left, with director Siân Heder on set of “Being Heumann.”
Apple TV
For Heder, the benefits of that approach went beyond authenticity. It also opened the door to actors she might not otherwise have encountered.
“An actor like Ruth is a gift, an incredible actor. … and the cast that I got to discover on this movie was incredible. It brought a sense of realism and a lived-in quality to the movie,” she said. “When you don't take the time to search for talent in these communities, you miss out on artists that you get to collaborate with, and by having a set that's not accessible, you miss out on these collaborations.”
Madeley pointed out that even with a disabled cast playing disabled people, there were still challenges. In her own case, the English actor not only had to learn Heumann’s Brooklyn accent, but she had to learn how Judy sat in a wheelchair.
“The way my body exists in the world is very different from the way hers did,” noted Madeley, who has spinal bifida, while Judy was paralyzed by polio as a child. “That was quite a challenge to show well and properly. Judy had no core strength, so she couldn't balance her body in the way that I can.”
In the years since the federal building occupation, the Americans with Disabilities Act passed in 1990 and ramps, curb cuts, wheelchair lifts and other accommodations have become more standard. Yet significant barriers remain.
Andrew Pilkington, from left, Siena Rafter, Charlie Rush-Reese, Dylan O’Brien, Roberta Colindrez, Ruth Madeley and Madeline Delp in “Being Heumann.”
Andrew Pilkington, from left, Siena Rafter, Charlie Rush-Reese, Dylan O’Brien, Roberta Colindrez, Ruth Madeley and Madeline Delp in “Being Heumann.”
Apple TV
Ruffalo has experienced this firsthand through his close friend, actor Christopher Thornton (“The Pitt” and star of Ruffalo’s 2010 film “Sympathy for Delicious”), who was paralyzed in a rock climbing accident. He recalled once carrying Thornton up three flights of stairs at a New York subway stop that lacked an elevator.
“I know even today how hard it is for him,” Ruffalo said. “I know his struggle, and it’s very personal to me.”
Nearly five decades later, the fight over Section 504 has taken on a new urgency. “Being Heumann” is arriving as the Trump administration rolls back protections under the Rehabilitation Act, including the mandate for the full integration of people with disabilities into American society.
Datebook Picks
The rapper Rexx Life Raj is hosting a show in the East Bay dedicated to his 2016 debut record.
MUSIC
His music changed after profound loss. Now he’s coming home to mark a milestone
Dancer and choreographer Chinchin Hsu.
DANCE
From a suitcase of rice to the S.F. stage, a dance about memory and home
The cast of American Conservatory Theater’s “John Proctor Is the Villain” rehearses.
THEATER
ACT’s ‘John Proctor Is the Villain’ gives ‘The Crucible’ a radical feminist makeover
“This story took place 50 years ago, but it feels incredibly relevant to me in the current moment,” Heder said. “We're in a time where people are being marginalized and made to feel invisible, and (back then) was a time when collective action worked. A lot of people came together to support this group in the building because it was like, if we are going to disenfranchise this marginalized group, then we're all in trouble.
“I think that's a moment that we're in right now. We have to raise our voices together because the powers working against us are more powerful than ever.”
Pam Grady is a freelance writer.
Nov 3, 2026
Pam Grady
… See MoreSee Less

How a San Francisco disability rights protest inspired the film ‘Being Heumann’
www.sfchronicle.com
A new film from “CODA” director Siân Heder revisits the 26-day San Francisco federal building occupation led by disabled activists.- Likes: 0
- Shares: 0
- Comments: 0
The San Francisco Monument
Dedicated to the Lincoln Brigade
Needs Your Help!
The Abraham Lincoln Brigade Monument in San Francisco features a display of archival photographs of the Volunteers of the Abraham Lincoln Brigade, both during the Spanish Civil War and in the years afterward, commemorating the Volunteers’ continuing activism throughout their lives. Dedicated on March 30, 2008, it is the most prominent monument in the United States to the veterans of the Spanish Civil War and the continuing fight against Fascism. The monument is located on the San Francisco Embarcadero.
The park complex on the Embarcadero where the monument sits is now slated for an aggressive redevelopment plan. This plan does not include the Abraham Lincoln Brigade Monument.
We urge our supporters everywhere to make their voices heard and help us protect our monument to the Lincoln Brigade. You can find ways to get involved below!
We encourage supporters to email the San Fransico Board of Supervisors in support of protecting the monument during this redevelopment process. A sample letter is below. The primary asks our supporters are making are:
Require a permanent, prominent, and accessible home developed with ALBA and artist Walter Hood, including consideration of design changes that could retain the monument within the renovated park.
Identify funding, a responsible City department and a firm installation timetable, with conservation safeguards and secure handling and storage during any move.
Provide readable, accessible panels and space for education, commemorations and community gatherings.
If a final site cannot be identified now, set a deadline for presenting alternatives and require a public progress report before the next design approval.
Sample Letter
To whom it may concern,
I write to you today about the Abraham Lincoln Brigade Monument on the Embarcadero, which honors approximately 2,800 Americans who volunteered to defend the Spanish Republic against fascism. They recognized the international threat posed by Hitler and Mussolini when much of the world looked away. Many never returned. Their courage and sacrifice belong permanently in San Francisco’s public memory.
When San Francisco accepted this monument, it made a commitment to those volunteers, their families, the artists and supporters, and then-Mayor Gavin Newsom and his administration, who helped bring it into being. Allowing it to disappear into indefinite storage or become an afterthought would break that commitment.
I respectfully ask for a commitment from the city government. That commitment should require:
• A permanent, prominent and accessible location, developed in consultation with ALBA and artist Walter Hood.
• Identified funding, a responsible City department and a firm timetable for installation.
• Appropriate conservation, secure handling and storage during any move.
• Readable, accessible panels and space for education, commemorations and community gatherings.
The monument cannot get lost in the shuffle. A renewed waterfront should help residents and visitors encounter this history and understand its continuing significance.
The Abraham Lincoln Brigade volunteers stood against fascism when doing so demanded extraordinary courage. San Francisco must keep faith with them.
Find Emails and the Comment Forms of the Supervisor and Mayor Below
The Mayor’s Office
Mayor Daniel Lurie – daniel.lurie@sfgov.org
The Board of Supervisors
Supervisor Connie Chan – chanstaff@sfgov.org
Comment Form
Supervisor Stephen Sherrill – sherrillstaff@sfgov.org
Comment Form
Supervisor Danny Sauter – SauterStaff@sfgov.org
Comment Form
Supervisor Alan Wong – WongStaff@sfgov.org
Comment Form
Supervisor Bilal Mahmood – MahmoodStaff@sfgov.org
Comment Form
Supervisor Matt Dorsey – dorseystaff@sfgov.org
Comment Form
Supervisor Myrna Melgar – melgarstaff@sfgov.org
Supervisor Rafael Mandelman – mandelmanstaff@sfgov.org
Comment Form
Supervisor Jackie Fielder – fielderstaff@sfgov.org
Comment Form
Supervisor Shamann Walton – waltonstaff@sfgov.org
Comment Form
Supervisor Chyanne Chen – ChenStaff@sfgov.org
… See MoreSee Less
What’s the deadline??
Jesse Welles on "This Land is Your Land" and Woody Guthrie's legacy
www.youtube.com/watch?v=TtXHQKjOlz0
CBS Mornings
216,531 views Jun 17, 2026 Extended interviews
In the series "USA to Z," which celebrates 250 years of American history and culture, Anthony Mason talks to singer-songwriter Jesse Welles about Woody Guthrie's legacy and the meaning behind the popular song "This Land is Your Land."
… See MoreSee Less

Jean-Pierre Thorn Dies: French ‘Dare To Struggle Dare To Win’
deadline.com/2025/07/french-director-jean-pierre-thorn-dead-1236451843/
Director & ACID Org Co-Founder Was 78By Melanie Goodfellow
Stories
By Melanie‘Cinghiale’ Horror Picture With Richard
Jean-Pierre ThornJean-Pierre Thornl'ACIDFrench director Jean-Pierre Thorn who was known for his socially engaged cinema and was also a co-founder of indie cinema org l’ACID has died at the age of 78.French media reported that Thorn who was born in January 24 1947 in Paris died unexpectedly on July 5. The director and activist was celebrated for his work “giving pride back to workers and immigrants” as he captured them standing up for their rights. Related Stories2025 Deaths Photo Gallery: Hollywood & Media Obituaries2024 Deaths: Photo Gallery & Obituaries2024 Hollywood & Media Deaths: Photo Gallery & ObituariesThorn first made his name as a director with the 1968 documentary Dare To Struggle Dare To Win (Oser lutter, oser vaincre).Capturing a historic strike at the Renault-Flins automobile factory during France’s 1968 social protests which saw workers and students unite it remains one of his best known works at home and internationally to this day. Reminiscing about the making of the film in an interview with the Les Mutins de Pangée audiovisual cooperative in 2023 Thorn said he had felt compelled to capture the workers’ side of the protests.“I said myself we need to have images of the workers’ movement. I felt that the barricades in the Latin Quarter weren’t enough… it was so extraordinary… ten million strikers that’s huge” he recounted. “I became obsessed with the idea of getting inside a factory.”“There was no video. We shot on 16mm. The challenge was finding cameras and film” he recalled noting that the film world was also on strike during this period.“A group of young cineastes got together to do ‘an active strike’… we were around a 100… loosely connected by the fact that we were close to Chris Marker and his work on Far From Vietnam. We pooled our cameras and film and that’s how I got started.”01:3709:16Thorn would go on to take a job as a metal worker at the Alsthom transport vehicle factory in the outer Paris suburb of Saint-Ouen staying there for eight years.During this time he made the 1973 medium-length film La Grève des ouvriers de Margoline which translates as “the Margoline workers’ strike” about industrial action by undocumented workers against poor conditions sparked by a rise in right-wing rhetoric against migrants as well as Le Dos au mur capturing industrial action at the Alsthom plant. Thorn branched into fiction in 1990 with Je t’ai dans la peau starring Solveig Dommartin as a nun who falls in love with a priest and then becomes a union and feminist activist. It premiered in Cannes‘ now defunct Perspectives cinéma français sidebar.Later credits included the documentary On n’est pas des marques de vélo which translates as “we’re not makes of bicycle” capturing the birth of the French Hip-hop movement through the case of a young French and Tunisian man threatened with expulsion.Thorn is also celebrated for his support of independent cinema as one of the co-founders of the France’s Association for the Diffusion of Independent Cinema (l’ACID). a press release paying tribute to Thorn l’ACID recalled how he had been one of 80 signatories of a 1991 text in support of independent cinema and entitled “Resister” alongside Claudine Bories Robert Guédiguian and Gérard Mordillat which acted as the spur for the body’s creation.The group secured support from France’s National Cinema Centre (CNC) for the creation of l’ACID which Thorn would preside over from 1992 to 1995.During this time he also negotiated with the CNC for the creation of the parallel l’ACID section at Cannes which to this day remains a champion of independent cinema during the festival.“For our association he represents an anchor in the memory of past and future struggles. Through his films we’re able to not lose sight of why we make films that maintain diversity and preserve our freedom and our autonomy” wrote l’ACID in it release.
… See MoreSee Less

Jean-Pierre Thorn Dies: French ‘Dare To Struggle, Dare To Win’ Director & ACID Org Co-Founder Was 78
deadline.com
French director Jean-Pierre Thorn, who was known for his socially engaged cinema and was a co-founder of indie cinema group l’ACID, died July 5 at 78.
Dolores Huerta was fearless about everything except her own flaws
www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2026-10-29/dolores-huerta-self-reflection
Dolores Huerta leads a rally in a black-and-white photo.
United Farm Workers leader Dolores Huerta leads a rally in San Francisco in 1988. (Court Mast / Associated Press)
By Matt Garcia
Guest contributor
Oct. 29, 2026 7:10 AM PT
The first time I met Dolores Huerta, she refused to shake my hand. In 2015, Cal State Bakersfield had invited me to commemorate the 50th anniversary of the grape strike that led to the formation of the United Farm Workers union. Huerta — who died Wednesday at age 96 —
had been among a group of former UFW leaders who protested my invitation because I had dared to publish a book that told the union’s tragic rise and fall story, in which she played a starring role. When she could not persuade the university president to rescind his invitation, she insisted that she be invited to share the stage with me. That day, as I approached her, I extended my hand, which she rejected with a scowl and a heel turn. In her address, she spent most of her time recounting her contributions to the farm workers and how they made possible a movement that both needed her and defined her. Absent was any admission of mistakes, regrets or failures.
That moment, for me, perfectly encapsulates a complicated woman who always fought to control her image and story. Her passing will evoke memories of this spring when she announced she was a survivor of sexual assault by Cesar Chavez, who also preyed on adolescent girls in the 1970s. While important, this version of Huerta conceals the woman I remember most from the movement I document in my book.
The child of a father who belonged to the United Mine Workers, Huerta as a potential leader of a diverse farm worker movement flowed mostly from her mother, Alicia. After divorcing Huerta’s father, Alicia eventually landed in Stockton, where she owned and operated a restaurant and hotel in the Filipino community with her new husband, James Richards. At a young age, Huerta became familiar with Alicia’s Filipino clientele, who had long expressed their discontent with exploitation in the fields where they worked. Alicia’s marriage to Richards ended, but she held on to the hotel, where Huerta worked and became friends with many of the Filipino farm workers who rented rooms. This fact would be consequential once Filipinos and Mexicans realized their shared destiny under one union.
Living in Stockton in 1960, Huerta first saw the virtue of participating in a new civil rights group dominated by Mexican Americans known as the Community Service Organization. It was Chavez who convinced her, Gilbert Padilla and others to join to swing its organizational capacity to address the needs of farm worker communities. When Chavez determined that they could realize that goal by breaking away to form a new organization, Huerta was among the first to go with him. In 1965, when the Chavez-led effort began to converge with the more assertive labor actions by Filipinos well known to Huerta, it was she who helped bridge the cultural and linguistic divide between Mexicans and Filipinos. When the new union initiated the first grape strike in 1965, it was Huerta who stood atop a car with her outstretched arms holding the sign emblazoned with “Huelga” (Strike, in Spanish) that became one of the iconic symbols of the movement.
And it was Huerta who figured out the keys to the movement’s success in the years that followed, particularly her innovation with the boycott. She had been among the first to try out the tactic in the winter between 1965 and 1966, when she, Padilla and others went to Los Angeles to appeal to unionized dock workers not to unload products made with grapes from farms where the union had set up picket lines. In the months and years that followed, she helped evolve the tactic from targeting finished products like wine that had a long shelf-life to perishable grapes that became less valuable the longer they sat on the docks or in grocery stores. She was in New York City in 1968 when growers successfully pursued an injunction against the Seafarers Union to stop them from collaborating with Huerta to block the shipment of grapes from New Jersey to Manhattan.
Like a quarterback calling an audible, Huerta responded by telling volunteers to relocate from the wharves to storefronts to ask consumers to support farm workers by not buying grapes. These moments show Huerta at her best, when she skillfully adapted to the conditions of the battle. Many volunteers, like Elaine Elinson, who trained under Huerta in New York, admired her flexibility and later applied her lessons elsewhere. Elinson, for example, used the same strategy in Europe, where she interpreted labor laws, the will of union leaders and the sympathy of consumers to determine which version of the boycott to employ. By 1970, these tactics delivered the first labor contracts to farm workers in California.
Huerta’s creativity waned as the movement increasingly became institutionalized and men, especially Chavez, assigned her necessary but sometimes thankless jobs. As a contract negotiator, Huerta frequently struck fear in the hearts of growers when she applied her considerable communication skills to achieving the best deal possible for workers. Just as often, however, people within and outside of the UFW judged her for leaving her children with other families or being too outspoken, revealing a double standard that existed for men and women’s behavior in the union and society at large. When Chavez began to make tactical errors or instituted controversial programs like a group encounter therapy known as “The Game” that broke the esprit de corps at La Paz, he demanded that Huerta co-sign these decisions and enforce his will. This included her participation in the purging of valuable volunteers from the union and eventually close friends and fellow founders like Padilla and Philip Vera Cruz in the 1970s.
Huerta, I believe, understood the contradictions of her choices but chose not to confront them — not on that day in September 2015 nor later. How could she not understand the contradictions, given her disclosure that she, too, suffered from the unchecked power of Cesar Chavez? In the last few months, I became more hopeful that she might ultimately reconcile these inconsistencies in her life. Would she finally recognize the pain she caused others by participating in their expulsion? Might she use her celebrity to draw attention to the other, lesser-known survivors? Sadly, these things never came to pass. Still, the record of her accomplishments and her testimony of sacrifice convey the extraordinary barriers we know she had to overcome and leave us to wonder what we still do not know about a union that fell short not because of her labor but in spite of it.
Matt Garcia is a professor of Latin American, Latino and Caribbean studies, history and human relations at Dartmouth College. He is the author of “From the Jaws of Victory: The Triumph and Tragedy of Cesar Chavez and the Farm Worker Movement.”
… See MoreSee Less

Contributor: Dolores Huerta was fearless about everything except her own flaws
www.latimes.com
In the last few months, I became more hopeful that she might ultimately reconcile inconsistencies in her life. Would she finally recognize the pain she caused others?Melinda Gould . Just like Chavez and Huerta created the new Union, we need to create the new political Party: THE WORKERS PARTY!
The 1934 San Francisco General Strike
speakoutsocialists.org/the-1934-san-francisco-general-strike/
July 12, 2026
Picket parade, Embarcadero, Friday May 10, 1934
Timeline
Dec 1932 – First publication of the Waterfront Worker
June 1933 – Section 7(a) opens the door for legal union organizing
1934
Feb 25 – Pacific coast convention votes to authorize a strike
May 9 – Longshoremen’s strike begins
May 15 – Maritime strike begins
July 5 – Bloody Thursday
July 9 – Funeral march for two murdered workers
July 12 – General Strike begins as Teamsters join strike and as solidarity strikes grow
July 17 – Vigilantes and police attack left wing offices and union halls
July 19 – General Strike concludes
October 12 – Arbitration award gives workers and union a significant but only partial victory
Introduction
In the decades before the 1930s, dockworkers at the port of San Francisco and other West Coast ports had been an abused, precarious, and downtrodden segment of the working class. Despite attempts at organization, they had been beaten back time and again by the powerful port owners and their capitalist allies and political representatives.
During the Great Depression and especially in 1934, the working class as a whole, and these port workers in particular, began a massive push to organize themselves and form unions. In doing so, they initiated an intense struggle between themselves and the port owners. This struggle took the form of a port strike in San Francisco and throughout the West Coast, which then morphed into a citywide general strike in San Francisco itself.
Tens of thousands of workers participated in organizing their developing unions, and in the financially painful and often violent struggle against the port bosses and their forces of repression. Throughout the strike and general strike that followed, the workers themselves took the lead in organizing fellow workers for the struggle. Militants with revolutionary politics played a role in shaping the union struggle on the docks and across maritime trades. Together they contributed to a groundswell of solidarity that forced concessions from the owners and the capitalist state. In these ways, the San Francisco General Strike is an example of what working people can accomplish whenworkers ina single industry do not fight alone, but rather spread the struggle across all working people of a region.
After the upsurge in Minneapolis in January 2026, and as some activists in the period began to think seriously about the possibility of a future general strike, we can benefit from looking back at the 1934 San Francisco General Strike. We can see what factors pushed it to commence, and what the working class did to organize themselves and carry out the struggle. We can also identify the challenges that they faced and that we will still face today if a general strike were to become a possibility.
The Decades Before the Great Depression
The San Francisco Bay Area and other cities on the West Coast became important ports in the mid-19th century. The workers at these ports, generally known as stevedores, worked hard labor with unpredictable schedules. From waterfront managers calling for “men along the shore” to work ships as they came in, these workers came to be called “longshoremen.” The work was physically demanding, requiring lifting and moving hundreds of pounds of bulky cargo. It was also incredibly dangerous, and workers had to be knowledgeable and alert to avoid serious and even life-threatening injuries that could be caused by dropping these heavy loads. They could also work for two or three days in a row, then be off for two or three days. They could work all morning, but when a ship’s hold was emptied, they might be sent home in the afternoon. It was “feast or famine,” even if the so-called “feast” was only enough to get them through the next day or two.
In 1851, shortly after the shipping industry began to develop on the West Coast, and in light of the dangerous labor conditions and high level of worker exploitation, West Coast longshoremen formed the Riggers’ and Stevedores’ Union in San Francisco. In 1853, they went on their first strike and won both improved pay and a 9-hour workday.
During the late 19th century and early 20th century, workers along the shore slowly became better organized. The San Francisco Riggers’ and Stevedores’ Union became affiliated with the larger International Longshoremen’s Association, or ILA. Workers who labored on the boats themselves formed their own union, the International Seamen’s Union, or ISU. Other workers transporting goods off the docks and on to stores and customers, like the Teamsters, were also formed in this period, and played a role in the work of the ports in the Bay Area. Longshoremen at other west coast ports also formed locals and soon also affiliated with the larger ILA. The ILA was, in turn, one member of the much larger American Federation of Labor, or AFL.
Port and shipping company owners were also getting organized. Through the local Employer’s Association, the local Chambers of Commerce, the Industrial Association of San Francisco, and their very own Waterfront Employers Union (WEU), the Bay Area capitalists organized themselves as a class to undermine, stifle, and in some cases violently destroy the nascent workers’ organizations. As a matter of course, their influence reached into the press, where they owned the local newspapers and magazines, and into the political sphere, with deep connections to, and influence over, powerful local and state politicians.
These two forces, the labor unions and the bosses, were increasingly coming into more intense conflict. In one instance in 1901 San Francisco, a strike began when Teamsters refused to handle goods produced by non-union workers. It lasted 11 weeks, included thousands of Teamsters, and spread into a number of other workplaces throughout the city. Bosses hired scabs and mercenaries, there was an open gun-battle on Kearny Street, five workers were killed, and hundreds more were injured in the fighting. The city’s mayor, responding to complaints of police brutality, said “if they don’t want to be clubbed, let them get back to work.” This was real class conflict, and most political leaders were clear about whose side they were on. Although the workers were forced to give up the strike when California’s Governor intervened and threatened martial law, the Teamsters managed to survive as a union.
In 1916 another strike took place in San Francisco, when 10,000 longshoremen up and down the coast struck to force the implementation of a new wage scale that had just been negotiated by the west coast branch of the ILA. Employers brought in strikebreakers, and even when an agreement was seemingly reached in which the workers would have gotten the new wage increases, the employers refused to remove those strikebreakers. This resulted in violence between the strikebreakers and the workers that caused the strike to intensify. All the biggest local and regional business leaders threw their money and influence into stopping the strike, and they pressed political leaders for a crackdown on the workers. Under intense pressure, the San Francisco Riggers’ and Stevedores’ Union backed down after six weeks, and in short succession other locals up and down the coast also gave up. Without coastwide solidarity, strikes of this nature would be difficult for workers to win.
In the first two decades of the twentieth century, tens of thousands of workers, particularly in the Pacific Northwest and along the West Coast, had some contact with, and were often influenced by, the militant workers of the Industrial Workers of the World (also known as the IWW or the Wobblies). The IWW called itself a union and led masses of workers in struggles to improve their conditions. Its core activists were united by the revolutionary perspective that workers, organized on an industrial basis and regardless of ethnicity or skill, could take control of industry away from the profit-mad bosses and instead produce for the common good. The IWW was particularly active in the western mining regions, the Pacific Northwest and the West Coast. They had many militants in and travelling through the Bay Area, and at least some of them were active in the 1916 strike. Harry Bridges, who only arrived in the U.S. in 1920, but would go on to be a leader in the 1934 strike, exemplified this type of militant worker. He was born in Australia and worked as a seaman in his teens, learning about socialism and international solidarity from the workers who sailed from country to country, and coming to see the working class as a class without borders. In 1920, he joined the IWW and from there became an active worker militant in the labor conflicts that would follow. Although Bridges soon left the IWW, it is clear that he and many other activists from the IWW were active in the area. In the longshore and shipping industry, militant, socialist ideas were in the air, and these ideas spread every time class conflict intensified.
Another, more consequential strike took place in 1919. This strike grew out of the radical upsurge that followed World War I, in which a wave of working class mobilizations spread across the United States. The end of the war, soaring price inflation for most basic goods, and the example set by the Russian Revolution, where workers and peasants took power in 1917, all contributed to this wave. Union leaders in San Francisco made radical demands like stock ownership and seats on the boards of directors for workers. Not only were the local unions not strong enough to engage in a long struggle, but as in 1916, not all the locals were on the same page in what they were demanding.
Radical demands like the ones they proposed triggered an aggressive response from the port-owning capitalists of San Francisco and the surrounding region. They pooled their money into an extensive anti-union propaganda campaign, intimidated judges and the legal system into prosecuting strikers vigorously, pitted local unions against one another to disrupt potential coastwide solidarity, and brought in Black and Caribbean workers as strikebreakers to stimulate racial divisions. With all these tactics, the port employers and their politicians defeated the strike.
Coming out of the defeat of 1919, the ILA and several other locals were severely weakened on the West Coast and in some cases completely eliminated, as happened in Seattle. In San Francisco, the port owners themselves formed a company union which they would dominate, and which would determine who could work and who could not. It was given the intentionally misleading name of the “Longshoremen’s Association,” and because their membership books containing the union’s constitution and tracked dues payments were blue, it was known as the “Blue Book” union. Anyone who was suspected of being a radical, or simply anyone who protested unsafe and unfair conditions, were all banned from the Blue Book union and could not get work on the docks.
After 1919, workers also became subject to a dehumanizing hiring process called the “shape-up.” Although this had always been practiced to some extent in ports on both coasts, and was always the preference of the port owners, it became the norm along west coast ports after 1919. The shape-up was a process where workers would show up at the dock early in the morning and wait. A boss or foreman would then choose the workers he wanted to work for him for the day. Sometimes he would choose only 20 or 30, even though there were 100 men waiting for work. The foreman would only choose workers who didn’t cause “trouble,” those who carried Blue Books, those who were of the same ethnic background as the boss, or who were willing to go the extra mile to satisfy their employer for the day. Often it led desperate workers to give kickbacks or outright bribes of money or liquor to the foremen in return for a chance to work.
The pervasive exploitation faced by the thousands of longshoremen up and down the coast, the use of the Blue Book as a tool of employer control, and the continuation and intensification of the shape-up were all driving forces that nurtured workers’ anger as the 1920s went on. While the bosses and their political elites could manage worker discontent in that decade with the tools they had developed, the situation would change with the worsening of economic conditions. It was then, when the Great Depression hit in late 1929, that the situation would begin to change, and workers would begin to organize in new and more successful ways than ever before.
The Great Depression
In late October of 1929, the Great Depression began. Triggered by capitalist overproduction and increasing banking and consumer debt that continued throughout the twenties and sparked in late 1929 by the mass selloff and devaluation of stocks on Wall Street, the Depression changed conditions considerably.
Within months, more than 600 banks had failed. Credit dried up, small businesses shut down, big businesses slashed production and their workforces, and farms and homes were lost to foreclosures. Millions of jobs were lost and official unemployment rates shot up to nearly 25%, but even this didn’t capture the true scale of the crisis. Soup and bread lines grew, evictions skyrocketed, Hoovervilles sprouted up, and desperate migration for work became common. Under these conditions, mass discontent began to rise. This could be seen in the growth and militancy of tenant unions and unemployed councils in all the big cities, the Bonus Army March of 1932 in Washington, D.C., farmworker strikes in California, the growth of new unions, and hunger marches demanding relief.
In this context of tremendous human suffering, people were coming to recognize that the system did not work for them, and revolutionary political views gained a new hearing among the working class. This was seen most clearly in the growth of the Communist Party (CP) nationwide, but also in California.
The Party had only formed in the United States in 1919, and under repression in the 1920s it remained small, winning thousands of members but never rising to 10,000. In California the repression was intense, there were few functioning cadres, and the Party operated mostly underground until the Depression. In 1930 its headquarters in San Francisco was even occupied by rival factions. These problems of small membership and internal division would begin to change as the Depression deepened and workers looked for more radical political solutions. The layer of workers who had been members of, or influenced by, the IWW before 1920 helped this shift to happen. Their ideas and experience bridged the gap between the earlier period of strikes and radicalism, to the Communist Party and its militants which would develop in the 1930s. By 1934 the CP had about 3,000 members statewide and dozens in the Bay Area, although according to a CP leader in 1933, they had no members actually working on the docks.
Organizing on the Docks
In December 1932, a small, four-page mimeographed leaflet appeared on the docks with a masthead that read, Waterfront Worker. It raised the issue of a 10-cent wage cut for longshoremen that had been handed down from the shipowners just in time for the holidays. The leaflet pushed the longshoremen to think about how they could fight this. It put forward the idea that they did not have to accept the Blue Book union’s power over their lives, and that they could organize for new conditions on the waterfront. It set its sights on the horizon “to prepare the whole waterfront between now and next December when the shipowners will try to put over another wage-cut.”
It quickly sold between 1-2 thousand copies for a penny each. It was published every week or two, with plenty of misspellings and errors. The articles were short and simple. They covered bread and butter issues that affected the longshoremen while making fun of different gang bosses or sharing jokes that could only be understood by the men who lived and breathed these experiences. (A gang was the common term for a work team of longshoremen.) It also reported current issues like the trial of Tom Mooney, a San Francisco labor leader and IWW member who was framed by the federal government for his political activism. Though the paper was based in San Francisco, it also was a way to share news across different ports on the west coast and even internationally.
In order to prepare the whole waterfront for the upcoming struggle against wage cuts, there would need to be a group to spearhead these efforts. Communist Party militants began to approach the waterfront with soapboxes and address the men waiting for the shape-up in the early fog. Their efforts were aimed at building their connections to the longshoremen and finding men that would want to organize a real fight back against the bosses on the docks.
This effort from the CP resulted in a group of perhaps a dozen longshoremen meeting in the Mission neighborhood, at a place that would be their namesake—Albion Hall, just off of 16th and Valencia. These meetings began as a Sunday morning class on trade unionism initiated by Communists, but militant longshoremen of various political views participated. The “Albion Hall group” would expand as the struggle on the docks heated up and go on to play a central role in offering a new and more rank-and-file leadership within the ILA.
The Tides Turn: June 1933
In the depths of the Great Depression, the United States Federal Government, then headed by Democratic President Franklin D. Roosevelt, passed a bill that would give encouragement to working people already beginning to organize themselves to fight back against their terrible conditions. Although the Democrats were reluctant to alienate their allies in business and industry, they wanted to slow or even halt the growing social unrest that was bubbling up throughout the nation. This bill, the National Industrial Recovery Act, was signed into law in June of 1933. Although it created the National Recovery Administration (NRA) and contained many provisions related to industry standards, length of work weeks and minimum wages, its most significant section for workers was Section 7(a). Section 7(a) granted workers the right to organize and bargain collectively without interference from employers—including the right to join a labor union of their choosing.
Working people across the U.S., downtrodden after years of government repression, stagnant leadership, big business dominance, and most recently the suffering of the Depression, jumped at the opportunity Section 7(a) seemed to offer them. Throughout the second half of 1933 and into 1934 hundreds of thousands of workers joined pre-existing unions and began to revitalize the union movement across the continent.
In San Francisco, the ILA exemplified this revitalization. A man showed up on the docks with the ILA charter, and as one longshoreman described, began “selling organized labor for 50¢ a piece.” This man was Lee J. Holman, the longtime forgotten president of the defunct ILA. He had the legitimacy of the nationally backed ILA charter, which was exactly what most working men had in mind when they thought about signing up for a union. One of the longshoremen recalled, “we didn’t have to be pushed to get into that union. We knocked down the god darned doors.” Men signed up in droves.
But at the first membership meeting, Holman set the precedent of his leadership style. He assigned all officers without any type of elections, and he actually had police remove a member from the floor of the meeting because he argued that the chairman of the meeting should be elected. He railed against the Communists and with them, the Waterfront Worker. He had always been and would continue to attempt to use the ILA to dampen down Communist influence, although with only mixed success.
This was par for the course for officials within the ILA. The president of the national ILA, Joseph P. Ryan, was notorious in New York for working with gangs, bosses, and using brute force to keep workers in line. For Holman and Ryan, the notion of a union was a charter on paper, yet with their own power to arbitrate. What workers wanted was not taken into consideration.
Nonetheless, by August, 4,000 men had joined the ILA to put a definitive end to the rule of the Blue Book and the shape-up. Despite this massive influx (90% of longshoremen in San Francisco), there was no clear direction given to the newly organized men. Holman’s conservatism held them back when they wanted to take action. He called for the men to wait for the Blue Book to be defeated in the newly created Regional Labor Board and in court. Even with this new influx of energy from below he refused to call for meetings or take action against the hated Blue Book, and opted instead to rely on government bodies or bureaucratic processes.
The Labor Board did not prove much help to the men. When foremen on the docks made rounds to collect dues for the Blue Book, some men weren’t hired again due to lapses in their dues payments. Their case was taken to the Labor Commissioner, and they ruled that “the Commission had no jurisdiction in the matter and that it was a case for settlement entirely between the men and the companies and probably the Recovery Act.” Still, Holman refused to take action, thus guaranteeing that the Blue Book would continue to be the rule of the docks.
This continued into September, when four men on the Matson Navigation Company docks were denied employment for refusing to pay their Blue Book dues. Yet again the various labor commissions refused to weigh in to help these men get back to work. And Holman and the ILA were unwilling to take direct action to protect their workers —”we don’t want any trouble right now,” he told them.
Unfortunately for Holman, the times were troubled already, and by attempting to keep his (and the men’s) head down, he only made it worse.
The fact that the ILA had burst onto the scene once more was aggression enough for the shipowners. They launched a “counter drive to get [the men] whipped back into line,” as an ILA official described it. On July 18th Martin “Whitey” Winblad was fired for lapsing on his dues for almost ten years, which was a regular occurrence and which for years many longshoremen had gotten away with without reprimand. The fact that one of their own, who did exactly as they did, was now out of a job, sparked outrage from even the most disengaged longshoremen. This was “a new development that immediately affected the livelihoods of hundreds of men on the waterfront.” Historian Bruce Nelson explains:
The offensive was concentrated at the Matson company, the largest employer in the port and the center of company union strength. At the shape-up on July 20 Matson representatives told the assembled stevedores, “Everybody has to have a Blue Book from now on,” thus initiating a lockout not only of ILA men but of anyone who wouldn’t—or couldn’t—pay his Blue Book dues. (Some delegates demanded payment of several years’ back dues in one lump sum.) Three weeks later an old-timer reported: “The Matson Lockout on non-Blue Bookers is still ironclad. . . They [would] rather go short-handed and rawhide those inside . . . than hire men who haven’t got the Blue Book.”
Arnold Hessler, another longshoreman, was hired on July 23rd on the Matson docks, and when he informed the foreman, he had no Blue Book, he was told to leave immediately. “I had been hired and thus was immediately discharged because of this company union and my refusal to comply with it. . . I had worked for Matson’s for about 3 1/2 years straight, and without a blue book either, . . . and I have been at Matson’s every day since, but have not been picked again. I didn’t belong to the ILA at that time but I am signing up now.”
In September, a special NRA board for San Francisco ruled that the Blue Book was “not a company union and is not under the control and domination of the Waterfront Employers Union.” The men were outraged. Men gathered on the Matson docks, tore up their blue books, and walked off the job.
By early October, Matson fired four more men, this time for wearing ILA buttons. The Waterfront Worker published a call for action, and a group of longshoremen led by Bridges went to the shape-up on the Matson docks to convince the men to refuse to work until the four had been reinstated. Four hundred longshoremen went on a wildcat strike for five days, and the company was told by the NRA board to rehire the men and not discriminate against ILA members.
This was a turning point for the union. As Bridges recalled it, it “demonstrated that you could join the union and wear your button, and if the company tried to fire you we had enough power to tie up the waterfront in order to enforce the demand.”
The organizing efforts throughout 1933 laid the groundwork for the course of the struggles in 1934. A new leadership was forming, one which was willing to organize for a fight on the job. At the forefront of this group was Harry Bridges. The Albion Hall group, which began to take responsibility for the publication of the Waterfront Worker, was adamant that the ILA leadership should be elected by the membership and be “men from the Waterfront, whom we know well.” They published these demands in the newsletter to prepare the readers for the ILA membership meetings, which they pushed to have with more frequency. They constantly drilled into their fellow longshoremen that they had to “take things into our own hands” and not leave decisions to the officials on high. These efforts were beginning to pay off.
In 1933 Bridges and others in the Albion Hall group ran an unsuccessful campaign in the election for top union offices, while managing to win two out of three business agent positions and a majority of the executive board. This gave them real influence within the local ILA bureaucracy. There was a dynamic emerging: these militant leaders had their finger on the pulse of the men on the docks and were gaining official influence in the ILA, but the top leadership positions were still held by officials who were loyal to the undemocratic and bureaucratic functioning of the conservative AFL union.
Nonetheless, when they raised proposals within the union they began to win votes and their proposals were put into effect. They fought for an early convention to meet in San Francisco in late February 1934. At the convention, demands were agreed on: $1 per hour, $1.50 for overtime, a 30 hour week, and – of huge significance – ILA-controlled hiring halls. This set of proposals was understood to be the only way to end the hated shape-up. There was also a coastwide referendum set for early March to vote on whether or not to initiate a strike. These would be fought for by locals along the entire West Coast with the intention of creating a coast-wide agreement for longshoremen, thus ending the isolation of each port.
However, while the left-wing militants were the driving force behind these demands, they did not come out of the convention with the upper hand. A coast-wide executive board remained under the control of the conservative officials.
When the March referendum took place, the longshoremen voted overwhelmingly to strike: 6,616 to 699. Holman, utterly disgusted by this “radical” turn by the longshoremen, begged Ryan to intervene and cancel all union meetings in order to ensure the conservatives in the ILA could maintain control. Facing this betrayal by Holman, the union membership voted to suspend Holman from the ILA. William Lewis, district president, stepped in and tried to call the strike off. His attempt was outvoted and ignored by the rank-and-file membership. The membership was looking for leaders who could lead them in a fight that could win their key demands, not sell them out for pennies. When Lewis spoke at mass meetings, the membership bypassed him and called for the more militant leaders like Bridges.
As March ran into April, and as May approached, it was clear there would be a strike whether the official leadership wanted it or not. Negotiations were going nowhere. Even with some concessions on wages or hours, the shipowners and union officials alike were not willing to accept or pick up the demand for a union-controlled hiring hall, which would effectively end the shape-up. President Roosevelt typed telegrams promising government mediation, which delayed the start of the strike. But as the union officials refused to fight to end the shape-up, decades of anger at the conditions on the dock made the men stand firm and get ready to head into battle. No arbitration board or presidential mediation could settle the bitterness they held in their hearts.
In San Francisco a 50-man strike committee was elected with Bridges as the chair. Preparations were underway for May 9th, the appointed day. Activists leafleted poor and working-class neighborhoods urging residents to support the strike and not cross the picket line. The Communist Party geared up to support and build for the strike. It did this through its unemployment councils and through leafleting working class areas.
The CP also played an important role in addressing the open wound of racial divisions. In previous strikes, Black strike breakers had been effectively employed against the largely white ILA. The militants on the waterfront, with the help of the CP’s influence, knew particular efforts would have to be made to organize Black workers leading up to the strike. Winning the strike would depend on this.
Black Workers and the Strike
In the early 20th century, Black workers in the Bay Area were a small minority of the population, hovering around 1% in San Francisco and 2% in Oakland (where the terminus for the transcontinental rail line was a hub of Black employment). Black workers were hired as scabs during every strike in the Bay Area starting in 1901. They would work during the strikes only to be laid off shortly after. After the 1919 strike, there were only a few docks where Black longshoremen remained on the job. One Black longshoreman thought back to his experience scabbing in 1919, which he saw as a “chance to crack the labor field,” because it “paved the way initially for negroes to get on the waterfront, because after the strike was over they began to hire negroes as longshoremen on the waterfront.”
While Black workers were also forced to use the Blue Book, the discrimination on the waterfront, as well as from other jobs, made their conditions worse. The discrimination came not only from employers and white workers, but also came from white-only labor unions which pushed Black workers out of jobs when they became unionized. Thomas C. Fleming, a journalist for The Spokesman, described the effects in the restaurant industry: “That color thing was very powerful. Up until the late 1800s, blacks had worked as cooks and waiters in some of the city’s best restaurants. But when the restaurants began to unionize, they wouldn’t accept blacks as members, and the black workers were replaced by whites.” Another journalist said the same: “for Aframerican workers in the Bay Cities, union labor has been and still is the chief obstacle to employment.”
Prior to the 1934 strike, the ILA was nominally open to Black workers, “so long as they accepted a limited and subordinate role.” For them, the main route to finding work on the waterfront was from strikebreaking, not from solidarity with other workers through a union effort. Sam Darcy (leader of the western division of the Communist Party) said that the ILA was overwhelmingly informed by a “passive attitude towards the question of Negro workers, and in some cases, actual antagonism towards including them in the Union.” These factors led many Black workers to see organized labor as a yet another barrier in a labor market that was already stacked against them. Black workers therefore had little incentive to respect the white-only picket line.
The 1934 strike would change the racial dynamics of the previously lily-white union. The radical leadership under the influence of the Communist Party took a different approach to the question of race among the longshoremen. In the weeks leading up to the strike, the Communist Party and Albion Hall group went into motion with the aim of ensuring the 1934 strike was not broken with the same racial divisions as the previous waterfront battles.
Two ILA members approached the local Black newspaper, The Spokesman, to publish a letter asking Black workers not to break the strike. The Spokesman refused on the basis that they did not have a clear enough program on how the unions would treat black workers. They changed their position soon after. Harry Bridges went to Black churches in San Francisco and the East Bay and promised Black workers jobs on every dock on the West Coast if they did not cross the picket line. An ILA strike bulletin promised union membership for any worker who had been on the docks for at least a year, giving Black workers more confidence that they could support the union and a strike.
They also approached C. L. Dellums, a leader of the Brotherhood of Sleeping Car Porters Union in Oakland, and appealed to him to help organize the Black community behind the strike. Dellums went to and spoke at meetings which were initially intended to recruit Black workers as scabs. Upon being recognized in the crowd (he was a prominent figure in the Black community), workers demanded the chair recognize him. By the end of his comments addressing the crowd of would-be strike breakers, he asked every man present to take an oath not to undermine the strike! (Meanwhile white longshoremen waited outside in case Dellums faced any security risk while addressing a scab meeting.)
Perhaps it was also the case that working class Black communities could begin to trust the sincerity of the message given the role that the Communist Party had played in political cases like the Scottsboro Boys, or perhaps because the Party had helped organize the Unemployed Councils and tenant unions that many Black workers were part of. Some Black workers, like Len Greer, became members of the Party themselves after being active in unemployed or tenants councils with other Party members. That union leaders like Bridges and others also had connections to the Party gave at least some layers of Black workers the sense that these union leaders were dedicated and sincere fighters for both Black as well as white workers.
A May 10 headline in The Spokesman captured the question that was being asked by Black workers in the Bay Area: “Longshoremen Appeal to Negro for Strike Support; All-White Policy of Union Tottering?” As the strike began, this question hung in the air, but was soon answered by actions from the union.
The newly formed ILA leadership made sure that Black workers were an essential part of the strike leadership. Despite the small numbers of Black longshoremen, the importance of breaking the color line meant that militant union officials like Bridges worked hard to bring Black workers into positions of leadership of the strike. One was chosen as a delegate to the coastwide strike convention and five were elected to the strike committee. In the first week of the walkout, a Black member of the strike committee was in the front ranks in a march of 5,000 longshoremen up Market Street, where they met a demonstration of workers 12,000 strong at the Civic Center.
On May 9th, the first day of the longshoremen’s strike, only a single Black longshoremen gang (comprised of 16 workers) joined the strike. Many Black maritime workers respected the picket lines but did not participate in them. While some Black stewards joined the white picketers, many were waiting for “proof that the white unions’ talk about racial equality [would] turn into action.” By the time the strike had ended, all the Black crews had joined the walkout, united with white workers in the fight to end their dependence on the modern-day slave market.
The West Coast Waterfront Strike
Men gathering on the morning of May 9th were no longer huddled in the chilly fog awaiting orders or desperately hoping for a day’s worth of poorly paid work. Instead, in San Francisco 1,000 men with their heads held high marched in pairs across the length of the Embarcadero, the waterfront road that runs between the piers and the rest of the city. In twenty ports along the coast, a total of 12,000 men gathered on picket lines. Ships stood anchored in the harbor, unable to move their cargo.
The docks were blocked off by barbed wire and thick, closed steel gates, with police standing guard. In San Francisco alone, nearly one thousand scabs were hired in the first few days of the strike. The bosses filled newspapers with words both begging and at the same time threatening the longshoremen to get back to work, and with ads looking to hire scabs.
The working population of San Francisco was overwhelmingly sympathetic to the strike. The first workers to show their support through action were the Teamsters, who worked side by side with the longshoremen as they hauled cargo off of the docks. On May 13th they gathered for a membership meeting and voted to refuse to work the waterfront. Mike Casey, the president of the Teamsters local, tried to block this, and when he failed, he immediately framed it as a defensive measure and distanced the Teamster’s action from what it really was. To the press, he claimed this was a “boycott” of the docks (not a sympathy strike), done only “for protection of the men.” Undeterred, hundreds of Teamsters left the union hall after the vote and marched to the waterfront to join their brothers in solidarity.
In the days that followed, the ripples spread outward from the docks as each section of working people were impacted by the strike and had to decide their course of action. The seamen were next, as they waited on the ships stuck in the harbor. In the first few days of the strike thirteen crews walked off the decks and onto the docks to join the striking longshoremen. Beyond just showing up in sympathy for the longshoremen, they began to formulate their own demands for their strike, also in opposition to the wishes of their conservative officials. By May 16th, the International Sailors Union and its affiliates (the Marine Firemen, Oilers, Watertenders and Wipers, and the Marine Cooks and Stewards) were also officially on strike. Other maritime unions demanded pay increases or other improvements but did not go out on strike.
Street battles broke out with increasing violence between scabs and strikers, and police force was used to break the strike. In Oakland, hand to hand fighting broke out when four hundred strikers stopped 72 scabs. In Portland, strikers attacked scab housing and “400 striking longshoremen threw one policeman into the water and severely beat several others”. In Los Angeles, on May 15th the police shot at strikers, killing two and injuring many more. A funeral march was held with 5,000 strikers and sympathizers in San Pedro.
On May 17th in San Francisco, a street battle was reported where 500 longshoremen “attempted to take 59 negro strike breakers from their police escort.” At one of the few piers where black workers had retained jobs from previous strikes, police intervened to disperse the gathering of white strikers. The police tried to escort the Black workers and then they told “the Negroes to ‘run for it’, which they did, followed by scores of shouting, fighting strikers.” They were in “their own territory” and ended up getting the upper hand over the stevedores in “hand to hand combat”.
Thomas C. Fleming tells of when he signed up to work on a ship being worked by scab labor. As they were loading into a truck to take them to the waterfront, the “wrong truck” showed up. “It was loaded with striking workers, and they had baseball bats, which they started swinging. We jumped off that damn truck and took off running. I didn’t try any more after that. I saw it was wrong then.”
Historian Bruce Nelson again provides a vivid description of the conflicts:
The most dramatic confrontation occurred in Seattle, where a timid and conservative ILA leadership stood by as employers put strikebreakers to work on every pier. In response, on May 12 a flying squad of six hundred Tacoma longshoremen, along with several hundred strikers from Everett and “all of the militant men we could find in Seattle,” stormed the docks. The army of two thousand men battered down pier doors, swept police aside, and halted work on eleven ships where strikebreakers had been handling cargo. The flying squad also paid visits to other cities, with so much success that a shipowner spokesman complained: “Within a few days all work at Pacific Northwest ports had to cease owing to violence by strikers and to lack of police protection. The strikers took over entire control of the waterfront.”
Violence from clashes between scabs and strikers was a daily occurrence at all the ports. The strikers were severe: patrolling by speedboat, cars, and by foot. If caught, scabs might have their legs laid across the curb and stomped on, or their teeth kicked out.
The bosses were skilled at using social divisions to their advantage. Many strike breakers were college students, looking to earn some extra cash. Several hundred scabs were Black men, and the violent clashes to defend the strike brought out racial antagonisms as well. Thus, it was particularly important to have African American longshoremen that could deter these clashes, by convincing Black communities and workers not to scab, and by confronting scabs when they did encounter them. Longshoremen like Len Greer tried to convince other Black workers of the necessity of interracial solidarity, which he saw as joining forces to “make a better future for yourself,” even when others in his community thought he was crazy for joining up with “poor white trash.” None of this was simple or straightforward. Greer had a friend who was stabbed on Pier 18 as he was cooking for scabs and after that carried a gun to defend his right to scab. Greer turned him into the police for the gun, though his underlying motivation was his friend’s refusal to give up his strikebreaking activity.
Despite these real divisions and how they were worsened by the bosses, the strikers managed to maintain their unity, and after six days of the strike, not a single freighter had left the port of San Francisco. The strikers along the coast were close to 22,000 total: 12,000 longshoremen, 5,000 sailors, and thousands from other maritime unions. The pickets held and the strike spread across the maritime trades. This despite the fact that there was no strike bulletin that came out consistently, and that there is no indication there were many regular meetings for the rank-and-file to gather to decide the course of the strike.
The conservative leadership of the ILA desperately wanted to call off the strike, get the men back to work, and appease the industrial bosses. Joseph P. Ryan, the ILA President, arrived in San Francisco from the International office in New York City to pick up the negotiations. During May and June he signed onto agreements that made various concessions to the company owners. In all these instances, the workers consistently voted down these top-down concessionary agreements. Their main grievance, the shape-up, had no solution in any of these contracts. The employers refused to give up control of the hiring hall and defended their right to hire union and nonunion workers. These contracts would have left the ILA powerless to end the most hated of their egregious work conditions.
On June 16, for example, Ryan signed a contract with the head of the Waterfront Employers’ Union (WEU), knowing full well he had no authority to sign an agreement on behalf of the membership. He had promised the shipowners his signature would be effective and he would “exercise the necessary authority” to get the longshoremen back to work. The agreement gave “joint and equal” control of hiring to bosses and the ILA, and the expenses for the union hall would be split. A labor relations committee would decide wages, hours, and work rules locally. It restricted new membership, pushed deadlocks into arbitration, and banned sympathy strikes. Ryan bragged about the agreement, and the newspapers all announced the strike was over. Local government cheered.
Bridges confronted Ryan outside his hotel and reminded him that he had no authority for the secret maneuvers he was attempting. The membership wouldn’t budge, and a contract would only be passed if it was voted on by two-thirds of the entire Pacific Coast membership.
This sentiment proved true at a meeting of 2,500 longshoremen that packed the hall and spilled over into the street. Ryan was greeted with boos and threats of violence. Bridges criticized Ryan for going above the strikers’ heads and conducting secret negotiations. The agreement was voted down unanimously in San Francisco. It was rejected in other ports but accepted by a narrow margin in San Pedro.
In the days following this meeting, both sides of the struggle increased their organizing efforts. Local governments ordered shipments of tear gas and arms as they prepared for battle. They mobilized their police forces and assured the bosses that the ports would be opened by force, now that the strikers had proved impossible to negotiate with.
For the longshoremen, Ryan claimed he “was not aware the strike was so widespread” across the different unions. He cried he had no idea that the solidarity strikes were taken so seriously by the strikers. The strikers were proving their resolve to remain out until all the demands were met across the various unions.
In order to coordinate further, the rank-and-file leadership created the Joint Marine Strike Committee to “carry on all future negotiations for a settlement of the strike.” The unions on strike had been meeting daily in informal sessions to coordinate, but now that was brought into a formal capacity through the committee. It was composed of five delegates from each union on strike. The Marine Workers Industrial Union (MWIU), the Communist Party organized “red union,” was asked to join but was voted down and rejected. The Teamsters were invited to join, but the president of the local told Bridges that “our refusal to handle goods in the waterfront is sufficient assurance that we support you.” This stance meant that the Teamsters were not only excluded from joint coordination, but also closed the door on the chance for the membership to elect delegates to coordinate their strike.
The committee organized a rally at the Civic Auditorium on June 19th. Ten thousand filled the seats and left standing room only. 40% of the audience were strikers, but the rest were families, friends and the general public of San Francisco. Amid speeches laying out demands and criticizing the bosses and the union leadership, the idea of a general strike was floated. For the first time, a sense began to develop that a general strike could be possible.
The next day the headlines of the capitalist press implored workers to settle for the June 16th agreement in order to avoid “bitter and disastrous warfare.” The newspapers screamed of the radicals, communists, and “alien” provocateurs on the waterfront. The temperature was rising: the official, bureaucratic methods of settling the strike had failed. The conservative union officials were impotent in stopping the strikers’ fight. Therefore, the bosses and their media amplified their divisive propaganda and the conservative leaders leaned to the right in an attempt to divide the strikers’ forces and settle it before it got out of hand.
Under this intense pressure to show how moderate and respectable they were, the San Francisco Labor Council met and overwhelmingly passed a resolution for the longshoremen to cut all ties with communists on the waterfront. The S.F. Labor Council even implored the Roosevelt administration “act quickly” to arbitrate the strike, because they feared they would not be able to stop a general strike if the bosses used force to open the port. The conservative union officials were still trying their hardest to pull on the reins and slow down the momentum that was quickly carrying the strike beyond their control.
After the June 19 meeting, some unions began to consider and then vote on what they would do if the governments and port-owners tried to use force to reopen the port. Some voted they would walk out, while others, like the Teamsters, voted against any notion of a general strike. But as workers were weighing how best to stand up to employer and state violence, the idea of a general strike was being contemplated. The strike committee met on June 30th and started to take up the question of how to organize for a general strike. Although a general strike had first been mentioned just three weeks into the strike, it was only after six weeks that efforts began to solidify this as a real possibility.
The employers were also divided as to the strategy to take to open the port. Should they let the strike wear itself out? Or bring it to a head-on collision? By late June, they were escalating preparations to use force: amassing freight trucks to use to move cargo, and with the promise of the Chief of Police that they would “do everything possible to handle the situation” for the employers. Despite an intervention from Secretary of Labor Francis Perkins pushing for federal arbitration, the Mayor pushed back and reiterated that even though it would involve bloodshed, the port would be forcibly opened.
As industrial actions spread through the country in 1934, the Roosevelt administration was developing its methods of managing the increasing class conflicts. On June 26th, they created the National Longshoremen’s Board to navigate disputes, investigations, and conduct elections for collective bargaining representatives. In other words, they wanted to bureaucratize the decisions and take decision making power away from the masses of longshoremen who were actually on strike.
The following week, the Board held a series of meetings with dates chosen to open the port, only for those dates to be pushed back. The Board came to the conclusion that the main issue holding back a settlement was the fact that the unions were trying to win simultaneous demands that would apply to all union locals. The bosses refused to deal with these generalized demands of the workers of San Francisco. They desperately wanted to divide them, pick each of them off and settle individually, diluting their larger potential power that could win gains for all workers in various sectors. But the strike committee held strong and refused to budge on their commitment to settling the strike together.
Bloody Thursday
On July 2nd, thousands of workers gathered on the docks, with approximately 4,000 standing in front of Pier 38, where it was expected that the companies would try to open to docks. They had announced the pier would be opened by force at 3pm. Police presence was overwhelming, but so was the crowd that had responded. A 21-hour delay was announced, and when the crowds dispersed in the afternoon, trucks slipped through the picket lines. A committee of strikers were escorted by police behind barbed wired gates to verify that further trucks were not being loaded.
On July 3rd, the crowds gathered even earlier in the day. The air was tense. Historian David Selvin described the beginnings of the conflict.
At 1:27 P.M., the steel doors of Pier 38 rolled up. A string of police cars led the way for five old trucks, two men on each truck. “They look scared,” said one reporter. A thunderous shout greeted the clumsy, little parade as still more police – on horses and motorcycles and in cars – joined the escort. The crowd surged forward. Barrages of tear gas opened the way for the trucks. The police moved on the crowd, nightsticks flailing. Slowly, the crowd fell back, breaking up into smaller, rock-throwing clusters, fleeing in retreat. Sounds of revolvers and riot guns echoed over the clash. Pickets fell back to 2nd and Brannan streets, some to Townsend. Bricks and stray bullets crashed windows; one stray bullet penetrated a window of the American Trust Co. at 3rd and Townsend streets, wounding a teller.
Amid these battles, five trucks made 18 round trips off the docks, and the next day, July 4th, ads from the Industrial Association in local newspapers declared emphatically: “The Port is Open.” Although they mostly respected the day as a holiday, they refocused their efforts towards Thursday, July 5th, when they would open the port in a definitive battle.
A little after 8am on the 5th, the gates of Pier 38 opened again and lines of police on foot, in cars and on horses began to escort more trucks off the docks and into the city. As the number of strikers and onlookers swelled, the police were ordered to attack. Tear gas was fired, and police then charged into the crowds.
The furies of street warfare raged for hour piled on hour,” the Chronicle’s Pulitzer prize-winning reporter, Royce Brier, wrote. “Don’t think of this as a riot. It was a hundred riots, big and little, first here, now there. Don’t think of it as one battle, but as a dozen battles.” But battles or riots, they were lopsided contests. Against the tear gas grenades, riot guns, and revolvers of the police, the pickets were virtually weaponless, grabbing at bricks or stones, pieces of lumber or construction scraps. Against the police mounted on horses and motorcyles, and in squad cars, the pickets could only run, in panic and terror, from their constantly reinforced and heavily armed attackers.
In the early afternoon, roughly six thousand strikers were concentrated near the ILA hall on Steuart Street. A car pulled up and two policemen jumped out and shot into the crowd. Three men were shot, two killed.
The murders of Howard Sperry and Nick Bordoise were declared “justifiable homicide” in the act of suppressing a riot. Over 70 strikers and sympathizers were shot (many of them in the back) on that day, earning it the name “Bloody Thursday.”
One bystander recounted that the police were the initiators of the violence: “Such rioting as occurred, was the direct product of their own aggression.” Of course, the Chief of Police did not see it that way: “we were faced by from five to seven thousand infuriated men bent on” causing violence to nonunion men, and destroying company property, and of course, he concluded, “after that, only the imagination can determine what they would have done in the way of sacking San Francisco.”
While the mayor and the employers called for the union to officially give up, the strikers refused. The Strike Committee called on all local unions to send delegates to Eagles Hall on Saturday, July 7th to prepare for a general strike.
The governor called out 1,500 National Guard troops and 5,000 more on reserve. Troops covered every pier along the Embarcadero from Fishermen’s Wharf to Islais Creek, armed with bayonets and machine guns. It was this level of force that was required to forcibly open the way for trucks to run from the docks to the warehouses.
In other ports the violence was immense. In San Pedro alone there were five hundred arrests over the course of the strike. The Los Angeles Police’s Intelligence Bureau was called “unbelievably sadistic” for the “campaign of brutality and terrorism indulged in… in the confines of the harbor department jail.” One sailor remembers going to the picket line on July 16th and being taken to the police station, where a cop beat him until he broke his shoulder and shins. “Then he twisted the right foot until the bones he had splintered with his club cracked and came thru the flesh, severing an artery. It started [to] hemorrhage and the blood simply poured out of me.” He remained in the hospital until August 14th and in a cast far longer.
The General Strike
The “high tide of united labor action in San Francisco” washed over the city in the week following the killing of Bordoise and Sperry. A somber funeral march of nearly forty thousand marched up Market Street in silence. One marcher recounted: “an ominous silence among spectators and marchers alike.… The sound of thousands of feet echoed up that hollow canyon—nothing else…. It was a magnificent sight—those careworn, weary faces determined in their fight for justice thrilled me. I have never seen anything so impressive in all my life.”
Years later, workers would recall this day “with awe and pride”. Even businessmen walking down the street took their hats off, as the overwhelming severity of the atmosphere washed over them. No policeman dared show their face. Row after row of men, marching shoulder to shoulder, marched with absolute discipline and sobriety.
Any hope of arbitration had collapsed. The fight for control of the hiring halls was a battle that would be fought until the end. There was no chance of leaving this up to an arbitration board. Instead, the only option was to expand the struggle beyond the confines of the maritime strike.
The Labor Council met on July 6th as hundreds of participants packed the room, the halls, and the street outside. 14 unions already supported a general walkout, and the Joint Marine Strike Committee brought a proposal before the Council for a general strike. The conservative Labor Council officials were forced to act. They either got out in front of the current wave, or they would be swept aside, powerless to control the direction of the movement. A union official described the situation: “It was an avalanche. I saw it coming so I ran ahead before it crushed me.” The momentum of the entire working class of San Francisco forced the union bureaucrats to get out in front of a movement they had consistently opposed from the beginning.
Thus, the Labor Council formed a “Strike Strategy Committee” (which the Communists called the “Strike Tragedy Committee”) and appointed AFL representatives from various unions. None of the representatives were from the waterfront unions. The goal was to get out ahead of the situation and lead it in a direction acceptable to them. George Kidwell, a sharp union strategist and part of the Teamsters and Bakery Wagon Drivers’ Union, articulated his aim in creating the Strike Strategy Committee. He explicitly wanted to get the strike “out of the hands of the individual unions, particularly the longshore, and get it into the hands of the Labor Council.”
The conservative leaders had succeeded in taking the reins back from the more radical layers of rank-and-file leaders in the maritime unions. To do this well, Kidwell had a twofold strategy: “first, to force both the employers and the marine unions to accept arbitration; and second, to turn an avalanche of class feeling into an orderly and limited expression of sympathy.”
Kidwell’s views represented much of the Labor Council’s membership and the union officialdom. He in particular had learned from the Seattle General Strike in 1919 and was very clear: “In a general strike situation, you’ve got to end it fast.” He knew the best way to do this was to create a general body that has “the loyalty of the people involved” but which is able to “control the situation” and “work out a solution” – meaning, end the strike.
The new, militant leadership did not expose what the conservative bureaucrats were doing. Instead, the July 7th ILA Strike Bulletin read “The San Francisco Labor Council has not blocked a general strike. The Council has set up a committee to make plans for a strike that will stop every industry in the city.” By publishing such an empty analysis of the forces at play, it critically failed to prepare the population of the city to keep up the momentum towards a general strike.
They continued to press forward with the strike, even while being out maneuvered politically and tactically by the conservative officials. Even if maneuvers to keep control of the strike in the hands of the most active unions were to fail, the least the militants could have done would have been to expose to the population what was happening. Not only did they fail to explain clearly who was selling out the strike, they also failed to propose ways for mass meetings of longshoremen and maritime strikers to regain control of the direction of the strike.
All throughout the Bay Area, workers were meeting and voting to go on strike. Workers without unions discussed what they would do as others walked off the job. Official union leaders pleaded with workers to delay their strike, but their pleas had little impact on the votes. Across the Bay, the Alameda Labor Council formed its own strike strategy committee.
The Teamsters gathered 1,500 of their members into the Dreamland Auditorium. Their local president reflected on the sentiment: “In all my thirty years of leading these men, I have never seen them so worked up, so determined to walk out. I don’t believe any power on earth can prevent their going on strike unless the marine strike is settled by Thursday.” The conservative union leader tried his best to undermine the strike, but his efforts had no effect on the determined upsurge of workers.
On the morning of Thursday, July 12th, 4,000 Teamsters across the Bay Area joined the strike. Over the course of the next two days, tens of thousands of other workers joined the strike, which now surpassed 30,000 workers in San Francisco alone. Two dozen more unions had voted to walk out if the Strike Strategy Committee recommended joint action.
Workers were taking matters into their own hands. Teamsters posted picket lines around the area, blocking non-union drivers. They issued permits for deliveries of food and fuel to essential services. Grocery stores rationed their wares. Gas stations shut down due to lack of supplies. Those who were able fled the city out of fear of lack of supplies. The rest filled strike kitchens and showed up to picket lines.
…….
… See MoreSee Less
DOCUMENTARY LENS
‘Who Killed Alex Odeh?’ Asks Good Questions About a Terrible Death
www.nytimes.com/2026/10/30/movies/who-killed-alex-odeh-review.html
The film by Jason Osder and William Lafi Youmans examines the 1985 pipe-bombing of a Palestinian activist in California, tracing the case to suspects in Israel.
An archival photo set in a home shows a man in a white shirt and black tie surrounded by little girls in white dresses.
Alex Odeh with his children, from left, Helena, Samya and Susan.Credit…Watermelon Pictures
Alissa Wilkinson.webp
By Alissa Wilkinson
Oct. 30, 2026
Who Killed Alex Odeh?Directed by Jason Osder, William Lafi YoumansDocumentary, Crime, MysteryNot Rated1h 23m
Find Tickets
When you purchase a ticket for an independently reviewed film through our site, we earn an affiliate commission.
From its title, you might reasonably expect that “Who Killed Alex Odeh?” (in theaters) would be a typical true-crime documentary, bent on investigating a death and revealing the perpetrator. It’s anything but that.
Directed by Jason Osder and William Lafi Youmans, the film has no easy answers. It’s largely interested in the context around the death of Odeh, a Palestinian activist and the West Coast regional director of the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee. On the morning of Oct. 11, 1985, he opened the door of his office in Santa Ana, Calif., and was killed when a pipe bomb went off. Odeh was mourned by many, including his family and community leaders, who praised his work on interfaith unity among Muslims, Jews and Christians.
But others voiced different sentiments. In the documentary, which makes extensive use of archival footage, we see Irv Rubin, then the chairman of the Jewish Defense League, tell a reporter: “I have no tears for Mr. Odeh. He got exactly, apparently, what he deserves.” The league, an extremist right-wing vigilante group, denied involvement in the bombing. But in the days after Odeh’s death, the F.B.I. identified the league as “the possible responsible group,” and several members fled to Israel.
Yet, despite the F.B.I.’s promises to continue the investigation, decades passed without a suspect being identified, and Odeh’s family mostly stopped expecting to ever learned who killed him. (Last year, on the 40th anniversary of Odeh’s death, the F.B.I. released a statement seeking information from the public on the case.)
That story is told early in “Who Killed Alex Odeh?” But the film soon pivots to the Israeli investigative journalist David Sheen as he takes up the story. He quickly finds information online that leads him to the whereabouts of the men who fled to Israel, information that investigators had said was unavailable, which makes him question why the case has not been solved before now.
And by making use of news footage, older video shot at fund-raising events and fresh interviews, the filmmakers trace both Sheen’s investigation and the broader strokes of right-wing activism and conflict in the West Bank since the 1980s. Some scenes are shocking, like hard-right leaders talking with Sheen and the filmmakers about supporting violence.
There’s a lot crammed into this movie, which makes it feel a bit haphazard at times. Perhaps more important, the focus on Odeh’s death somewhat eclipses his life: We hear briefly about his work, but it seems as if there’s a lot more that could have been explored, creating an added layer of emotional stakes for the viewer.
But there’s a lot to admire here, too. “Who Killed Alex Odeh?” is revealing, and by centering the story on Odeh’s death, it keeps human emotion at the core of the mystery. The film’s refusal to fall into easy true-crime tropes or seek a definitive answer shows just how difficult it has been for his family to feel peace. And the questions it raises — about why the case has been left unsolved for so long and about what it all means — are troubling and profoundly urgent.
… See MoreSee Less

‘Who Killed Alex Odeh?’ Asks Good Questions About a Terrible Death
www.nytimes.com
The film by Jason Osder and William Lafi Youmans examines the 1985 pipe-bombing of a Palestinian activist in California, tracing the case to suspects in Israel.
‘Possible Love’ Review: The Lives of Others & Class Struggle
In his first movie since his celebrated drama “Burning,” the South Korean director Lee Chang-dong focuses on two couples from very different worlds.
www.nytimes.com/2026/10/22/movies/possible-love-review-the-lives-of-others.html
An image of a man, child and woman looking outside from a window.
From left: Sul Kyung-gu, Jeong Seop, Jeon Do-yeon in “Possible Love.”Credit…Netflix
Manohla Dargis.webp
By Manohla Dargis
Oct. 22, 2026
When you purchase a ticket for an independently reviewed film through our site, we earn an affiliate commission.
“Possible Love” is an absorbing, humane drama with a lacerating political edge. It was directed by the filmmaker Lee Chang-dong, whose movies include “Burning” (2018), about a fatal love triangle and other catastrophes, natural and not. “Possible Love” involves two couples in South Korea whose lives overlap first with smiles and then shivers of violence. One couple is wealthy and the other is struggling badly, and their circumstances are so dissimilar that they might as well live on separate planets. They don’t, which makes this story — about some people who break and others who do the breaking — a tragedy for these times.
Some movies announce their intentions with self-important flourish, slathering on their ideas and themes with a trowel. Lee takes a more discreet, nuanced approach in “Possible Love,” easing into the narrative obliquely with slices of life that are rich in incisive, resonant detail. It opens on a naturalistic scene of a husband and wife heading to a funeral with their son. The father tells the boy to tie his shoelaces, the neighborhood comes into view — there are modest houses, some sporty passers-by — and the mother sighs, burdened by an unspoken weight. Once at the funeral, the husband and wife argue about his drinking, while a woman, who’s making a documentary on the fate of laborers, records them on camera.
YouTube video thumbnail: Possible Love | Official Trailer | Netflix.jpeg
The story emerges unhurriedly, with a lifelike steadiness that Lee punctuates with flares of emotion. The filmmaker, Ye-ji (Cho Yeo-jeong), is looking to make her mark and, to that self-interested end, has decided to focus on workers, a topic that she doesn’t think receives enough attention. When she pitches her movie to some backers she sounds enthusiastic, if mostly about the promise of her project. Awareness of her subjects, or something like it, only comes long after she meets the bickering couple from the funeral, which was for the colleague of the husband, Ho-seok (Sul Kyung-gu). Several years before, he and the colleague had been on a strike that the government violently squashed, crushing a movement and destroying futures.
Written by Lee and Oh Jung-mi (they did “Burning” together), the movie soon narrows in on the two couples, though, most crucially, Ho-seok’s wife, Mi-ok (a tremendous Jeon Do-yeon). Although Ho-seok doesn’t want to be interviewed for the documentary, she eagerly volunteers. She’s a bright, curious and vibrantly alive woman; unlike her husband, the light in her eyes hasn’t been extinguished. Mi-ok works in a small company that makes surgical masks, and the documentary gives her something to do other than punch the clock and care for her family, including a son of around 10, Cheol (Jeong Seop). It also brings her in contact with people whom she would likely never meet unless she was working for them.
Image
An image of two families at a dinner table.
From left: Zo In-sung as Sang-woo, Cho Yeo-jeong as Ye-ji, Jeon Do-yeon as Mi-ok, Sul Kyung-gu as Ho-seok.Credit…Joo Jae-bum/Netflix
“Possible Love” builds on parallelisms in sharply distinct spaces, with the watchers and the watched, the exploiters and the exploited, the stubbornly alive and the nearly dead. Ye-ji’s husband, Sang-woo (Zo In-sung), pulls into the complicated mix, arriving early and conspicuously in a Porsche. A tall man with the untroubled face and casually domineering physicality of frictionless wealth, he could be one of the guests milling about in the background of “The Great Gatsby.” Sang-woo towers over everyone, and he dazzles Mi-ok, who’s openly taken with him. If he scarcely seems to notice her at first, it’s because he doesn’t seem especially interested in other people. He and his wife are careless people, to borrow again from Fitzgerald. (“There are many so Gatsbys in Korea,” one character tells another in “Burning.”)
“Possible Love” opens with the biblical injunction “thou shall not covet,” suggesting a way into what follows. (The final credits also include a nod to “The Decalogue,” the Polish director Krzysztof Kieslowski’s epic meditation on the Ten Commandments.) There’s a lot of coveting in “Possible Love,” some of it humorous and much of it expressed by the women. Soon after Mi-ok agrees to be interviewed for the documentary, she clandestinely looks up the price of one of Ye-ji’s purses, eyes widening in near-cartoonish shock. That the poor couple has something that Ye-ji covets, in turn, is evident each time she turns on the camera and records another strike participant’s pained memories, smiling in sympathy as she laps every tear.
The strike is crucial to “Possible Love,” and introduces a transactional world that has nearly destroyed Ho-seok, hollowing him out. It’s a relationship that Ye-ji replicates, wittingly and not, on a far smaller scale while making her documentary. Lee doesn’t push this resemblance too hard, but instead incorporates it into a constellation of ideas involving the dignity of work, the imperative of self-worth, the hunger for authenticity and the stories we tell ourselves and others. Ye-ji’s single-minded focus on making her documentary can be appallingly insensitive, yet she — like Ho-seok — finds purpose in work. That she, though, needs to parasitically borrow from other lives to find meaning is pathetically, poignantly modern.
Lee adds layers upon layers in “Possible Love,” thickening its realism with pungent details, like an old whistle that Sang-woo cherishes as a memento. He keeps it on a shelf in his family’s seaside home, a mansion that the couples visit one tumultuous weekend. It’s there amid the lush grounds, over glasses of pricey wine and drunken karaoke that everything — desires, grievances, class differences and bitter histories — converges with a howl. Sang-woo’s grandfather used the whistle when he was a policeman (implicitly in Japanese-occupied Korea); when Sang-woo was a child, he blew it to summon the caretaker’s son. “He would come running,” Sang-woo says. That boy grew into a smiling servant who you see at the mansion. He looks as if he has never raised a fist in solidarity like Ho-seok once did, much less learned — like Mi-ok — to say no with the crystallizing power of self-determination.
Rated R for language and a brief sexual scene. In Korean, with subtitles. Running time: 2 hours 44 minutes. In theaters.
… See MoreSee Less

‘Possible Love’ Review: The Lives of Others
www.nytimes.com
In his first movie since his celebrated drama “Burning,” the South Korean director Lee Chang-dong focuses on two couples from very different worlds.
Palestinian Arts Workers Call for Solidarity
www.labornotes.org/blogs/2026/10/palestinian-arts-workers-call-solidarity
October 07, 2026 / Mona Abharienlarge or shrink textlogin or register to comment
Seven women in long skirts and kerchiefs kneel, their arms in motion, apparently mid-dance. They are on a stage, bathed in red light..png
Members of the Palestinian Performing Arts Network performed on International Women's Day in 2017. The network represents hundreds of Palestinian dancers, actors, musicians, playwrights, and circus performers. Photo: PPAN
Palestinian cultural workers living through apartheid, occupation, and genocide are calling for solidarityfrom their counterparts abroad.
Not every artist has as large a platform as rapper Macklemore, children’s TV star Miss Rachel, or country singer Zach Bryan—who wore a “Free Palestine” shirt last weekend while playing a packed show at the same stadium where billionaire Robert Kraft had barred Macklemore for saying those words—but there’s plenty that artists and art workers can do to end complicity in Israel’s ongoing atrocities.
We as Palestinians have long decried Israel’s war crimes and crimes against humanity. Now the Palestinian Performing Arts Network (PPAN), representing hundreds of Palestinian dancers, actors, musicians, playwrights, and circus performers, has outlined four ways that U.S. arts unions can lend solidarity:
1. Reject the blacklisting and censorship of members who speak out on behalf of Palestinian rights.
For example, British Actors’ Equity passed a motion in the UK’s Trade Union Congress, representing 5 million workers, affirming the right of artists to “critique institutions and bring attention to issues through overtly political art without fear of censorship or losing their public funding.”
In the U.S., over 700 entertainment industry union members signed a 2024 open letter calling on SAG-AFTRA to back a ceasefire, protect members from blacklisting, and condemn the targeting of journalists.
2. Refuse to work with institutions and corporations—such as venues, festivals, publishers, broadcasters, and foundations—that are verifiably complicit in Israel’s crimes against Palestinians, and divest union funds from such corporations.
In fall 2025, over 5,500 film industry workers signed such a pledge. Earlier that year, Norway’s actors union Norsk Skuespillerforbund (NSF) recommended that its members “reject work and collaboration with Israeli cultural institutions that operate in violation of the Palestinian cultural boycott.”
3. Exclude Israel from international labor federations such as the International Federation of Actors (FIA) and International Federation of Musicians (FIM).
4. Pressure governments to compel Israel to end its genocide and apartheid through lawful sanctions.
“Historically, including in the struggle that ended apartheid in South Africa, organized labor has been the working person’s leverage,” the PPAN said. “[Unions are] a powerful force for peace and justice when governments fail.”
UNION MOVES
Drawing inspiration from the global movement to end South African apartheid, Palestinian unions and workers have consistently called on unions worldwide to use sanctions, boycotts, and divestment (BDS) campaigns as pressure points to end Israel’s genocide and occupation.
The United Auto Workers has endorsed divestment from Israel bonds and acted on it. Since 2023, a smattering of Palestine solidarity groups across unions have pushed for pension fund divestment, joined other unions abroad to block arms to Israel at international docks, and protested complicit corporations>.
Copy%20of%20Untitled%20%282036%20x%20224%20px%29.png
The United Auto Workers, the United Electrical Workers (UE), National Nurses United, and the Painters have also thrown their support behind an end to military funding to Israel and divestment. UE also became the first national union to endorse the BDS movement.
Some rank and filers have been forming loose solidarity networks like Entertainment Labor for Palestine, Purple Up for Palestine (SEIU), CWA4Palestine, and IATSE Members for Palestine.
Union members can find resources like Ethical Investment and Ethical Procurement Policies to keep union pension funds and vendor contracts out of companies complicit in human rights abuses anywhere, including Palestine.
In the UK, on September 8, British Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband called illegal settlements in the West Bank “ethnic cleansing,” as part of the announcement of sanctions against Israel. Shortly thereafter, the UK’s Trade Union Congress, representing 5 million workers, endorsed the Palestinian-led BDS movement.
ATROCITIES ONGOING
The calls come as Israel’s ongoing genocide in Gaza reaches horrifying numbers. At least 80,000 Palestinians had been killed by Israel as of January 2025, which is likely an undercount as Israel’s destruction in Gaza is so extensive that it has obstructed our ability to even count our dead. Israeli settlers’ land theft in the West Bank has drawn condemnation from 12 countries including Canada, France, and Britain.
Over the past few years international human rights organizations and institutions from the United Nations and the International Court of Justice to Amnesty International and Israeli human rights organization B’Tselem have corroborated what Palestinians have been saying for years—determining that Israel is committing the crimes of apartheid, illegal occupation, and genocide.
Since 2023, a majority of the U.S. public has consistently supported ending military aid to Israel. Yet tens of billions of our taxpayer dollars continue to flow to Israel to fund its military actions, instead of being used to meet workers’ needs. Meanwhile working families in the U.S. face cuts to education, health care, and housing.
This is one practical basis for solidarity between workers here and in Palestine. Our tax dollars shouldn’t enable Israel’s war crimes. They should go to ensuring a dignified life for all, through more funding for social services, community needs, affordable housing, and accessible health care.
Mona Abhari is the North America labor organizer for the Boycott, Sanctions and Divestment Movement.
… See MoreSee Less

Palestinian Arts Workers Call for Solidarity
www.labornotes.org
Palestinian cultural workers living through apartheid, occupation, and genocide are calling for solidarity from their counterparts abroad. Not every artist has as large a platform as rapper Macklemore…
‘Digger’: US imperialism is digging our graves
9 October 2026
communist.red/digger-us-imperialism-is-digging-our-graves/
Harry Kent Culture and reviews, USA Articles, Issue 57
Alejandro González Iñárritu’s ‘Digger’ exposes the madness of US imperialism in its relative decline — to a mixed reception. Iñárritu brilliantly captures America’s crisis — but, unlike in the film, real-life workers cannot accept this fate, and are rising up all across the world.
Alejandro González Iñárritu’s latest film, Digger, has been received with controversy, as well as a spate of bad reviews from the bourgeois press. This refreshing, bombastic, and witty satire hinges around the climate crisis, but it goes much further. It lays the blame for the world situation at the feet of US imperialism and its aged, hubristic political representatives.
Digger is deliberately on-the-nose and states its position very clearly.
Digger Rockwell, a ruthless Texan oil baron, is portrayed in a rather absurd manner (but by no means an unbelievable one). This is the capitalist class today: obscenely wealthy, detached, stupid, and egotistical. This class has a contemptuous attitude towards its workers and is far more interested in profit — and, in the case of Digger, the health of his ailing cat — than preventing the destruction of the planet.
Workers on his oil project warn him of impending catastrophe, but Digger ignores their concerns. His workers were (surprise, surprise) right about his shortsighted profiteering. Digger’s arrogance sets off a chain of events that threatens the destruction of Europe and, ultimately, life on earth.
Sick system
The film’s POTUS, played excellently by John Goodman, encapsulates all sides of the American ruling class — a ruthless, sick, dying old man, leading a system in the same state.
The politicians and military chiefs discuss their options, from bombing the problem to smithereens, to blaming it on Russia and China, reflecting the situation we live in today. The US thinks it can bomb its way out of any problem, while constantly trying to blame the crisis on the bogeymen in the East.
Despite bragging about being the world’s biggest military power, the film’s hapless US officials are incapable of solving the crisis that they created, dragging the world down with them. Out of ideas, Digger suggests a mass censorship of social media to get away with their horrendous crimes!
It’s hard not to see a real-life analogy with the war in Iran. This massive military blunder by the USA — in no small way owing to its hubris — is revealing its weakening global position and exacerbating the world crisis.
Fourth wall
The film takes a turn at this point. We are actually watching a play within a film, with all the characters so far being played by actors in rehearsal. These sequences are reminiscent of Iñárritu’s Birdman, and introduce some interesting staging and camera work.
But the main purpose of this — in the style of Bertolt Brecht — is to break the fourth wall. We’re encouraged not to focus on character development, but the political message that the director wants to deliver.
That message is made abundantly clear: American capitalism is destroying the world.
Much has been made of the scene where Digger delivers his fiery monologue. According to most of the bourgeois press, this is the scene where Digger tells us — the audience — that we might hate him for what he did, but we all need him and are all guilty in the climate crisis.
This is a bizarre misreading of the film: Digger explicitly said he is at the European Parliament. Since when were the masses ever invited into this thieves’ kitchen?
No, Digger is actually lecturing the squabbling mess of European leaders. He reminds them that they are all shareholders in his company, that the Europeans are nothing without American oil or US capitalism.
Imperialist decline
Is this not an honest reflection of real life? US imperialism’s war in Ukraine resulted in a cut off of cheap Russian oil and gas to Europe, throwing Europe into an energy crisis.
Since then, the USA has strengthened its energy exports to the bloc — now 14 percent to 15 percent of its total crude, and 60 percent to 65 percent of its LNG imports.
The relative decline of the USA has profound implications for the future of Europe. US imperialism was once able to hold Europe together. Now that its position is threatened by the rise of China and Russia, it’s no longer interested in subsidising Europe. As a result, the European powers can either grovel to the White House, seek alliances with other stronger powers, or go it alone and fight amongst themselves.
It’s true that the film is ultimately putting forward a rather grim perspective. There are no depictions of the masses fighting back against the rotten individuals in power. But it would be false to say that it does not comment on the masses at all.
Film vs reality
The final scene of the film depicts the dystopian life that the embittered masses are now having to live — all for the actions of a hated ruling class and a system in which they had no say. While the film does not depict socialism, it certainly depicts the barbarism that capitalism — if unchallenged — has in store for us.
But, fortunately, we do not live in Iñárritu’s Digger universe. We are living in a world where class struggle is on the order of the day. Even as I write these words, school students across France are attempting to storm heaven, drawing in wider layers of the masses with them.
At the beginning of this year we saw the first shots of the American Revolution, with hundreds of thousands of workers across Minneapolis carrying out a de facto general strike that successfully defeated ICE.
Digger is a fun, entertaining, and daring film in an era of mostly un-daring cinema. The political points that it does put forward are sharp and astute. It faithfully reflects the world situation, which does appear absurd. But it’s not real life.
In real life, the future is communism.
… See MoreSee Less

‘Digger’: US imperialism is digging our graves – The Communist
communist.red
Alejandro González Iñárritu’s ‘Digger’ exposes the madness of US imperialism in its relative decline — to a mixed reception. Iñárritu brilliantly captures America’s crisis — but, unli…
